Friday, October 1, 2010

cultural appropriation: still refusing to see the truth

[a polaroid of a person outdoors, with long brown hair wearing a colourful native american inspired "war bonnet" and bright red lipstick. they are covering their eyes with the back of their hands and is expressionless. the text underneath the polaroid reads "Until mainstream society takes Natives seriously, it won't take Native issues seriously. Carticatures, mascots, costumes and cartoons don't need running water, after all." Sheena Rotman (The Signal)]
a page from kate burch's zine, head dress



in the year since i started this blog, the issue that has generated the most debate and discussion had easily been the critical fashion lover's guide to cultural appropriation. now that halloween is just around the corner, seeing images of white women in hypersexualized racist "indian princess" costumes is sadly serving as a reminder that this is issue will not go away without a fight. but we can keep the conversations going. sadly, today i feel disappointed, disenchanted, exhausted. it sucks that we still have to keep defending the very basics of why we think people should be thinking about cultural appropriation in the first place. here i go again.


[cartoon: in the first panel, a girl sits in a judge's stall with a gavel. a cat wearing glasses is dressed as a mariachi holding a bag that reads "taco taco." the judge rules "cultural appropriation." this continues with many foods, pizza, "hot stuff," "der very wurst," and a 3 potato salad. the last three panels are as follows: the judge watches patiently as cat sighs and reaches into a mcdonald's bag. in the next panel, the judge is eating fries and cat is eating a burger. the judge says, "it's so sad that the whole world eats mcdonalds." ]

my first reminder that the spirit of cultural appropriation is alive and well was when i was looking for a laugh: this week, i was disappointed with the latest cat & girl comic. i used to really enjoy their sardonic sense of humour, but this... it just kind of rubs me the wrong way. it almost seems to propogate this attitude of "you can't win" if you think critically about cultural appropriation. at the same time, i think i could understand why it would be funny to some people (perhaps it is a jab at the imposed dominance of american fast food culture on a global scale?).

but in the end, the imagery of the judge ruling wether or not a food item can be considered cultural appropriation only serves to remind me that it is really annoying/emotionally exhausting to constantly have to be on the defensive. to constantly have to explain the reasons why cultural appropriation, whether it be happening in a mall food court or on a fashion runaway, is potentially problematic and needs to be challenged. a common reaction when the subject comes up is "who made you the judge of everyone?" sigh. contrary to what many naysayers may believe, no, i don't sit in front of my computer actively searching for white girls wearing headdresses to argue with and judge.


created by elusis

rather, it's that images of models, of clothing catalogues, and of white girls in headdresses at concerts that attack and offend us: those of us who feel like these conversations are important to be having, that we have to ask these questions. i am fed up with it. fed up with seeing "Othered" cultures reduced to shitty stereotypes for uncritical (mostly) white people to buy into, as a product, and then to attack me when i ask them to think about what they are wearing, when i ask them why they choose to wear what they wear. is that such an offensive question? is it really us who are so hypersensitive and who take things "too seriously," or is it you who just wants to refuse to think for two seconds?



which leads me to katrina richardson's amazing article, Accosted by racist costumes. in it, she writes frankly and honestly about getting upset at an art festival after not only seeing two girls wearing headdresses, but walking into an art gallery called "The Eskimo Sisters." unsurprisingly, the gallery is not in fact run by Inuit women, or have any attachment or relevance to Inuit culture whatsoever (which is sometimes mistakenly referred to as Eskimo, which for the record has been frowned upon by Inuit communities and was largely removed from popular nomenclature in Canada and Greenland since the 1970s but is still used in Alaska). rather, according to their facebook page,
Eskimo Sisters is a new space in Providence for music, art, delicious treats, sparklers, general silliness, general seriousness, kittens, puppies, and magical unicorns.
oh, and i suppose the magical northern "Eskimo" people fall right into that category, too! what a perfect name! /bitchy sarcasm. to top it off, the term "Eskimo Sisters" supposedly refers to two women who have slept with the same man. we all know how much we love our racial naivety with a side order of hypersexualization, don't we?

richardson ends up confronting the two girls wearing a headdress, and asking them why they are wearing them. her article is definitely worth taking the time to read it in its entireity, but here are two important quotes:
I understood why the headdresses seemed like an attractive accessory. People want something closer to the ethereal and the spiritual. To look ethnic and feel closer to nature. But is their whim to play earthy mystic for a night greater than mine to enjoy an evening without feeling accosted by racist costume?
she concludes her powerful article with this statement:
I may grow wiser and regret my actions, but even if those women do remain clueless and forget everything I said, I at least made them uncomfortable for five minutes of their night, and right now, that's worth it, to me.
for her sake, mine, and other people who have been taking up this fight, i hope she is right. her experience reminds me of a lot of my own, of my internalized racism as a mixed race french-canadian/abenaki kid growing up. of playing cowboys and indians and always being relegated to the role of the "indian." of my own family's erasure and active denial of our native roots.


image courtesy of native appropriations

mainly, it reminds me last night. i went to see xiu xiu, a free concert organized by the city's university radio station CHYZ 94,3 and i was sadly reminded why i have stopped going to live shows. the entire night, i was distracted by this blonde girl wearing a headband with a few feathers sticking out, and blue paint smeared underneath her cheeks. all her friends had the same paint across their face, and at different points they were passing around the "native" headband.

it reminds me of last halloween, when i spent a half an hour in the bathroom calming myself down after a teenage girl i'd met a few times through mutual friends jumped up on stage to dance with we are wolves dressed as an "indian princess."

it reminds me of all of these times i end up feeling like shit, and have to convince myself that this is just me overreacting. all of these times i overthink the entire situation, wondering what i should do, what i could say, to simply encourage people to maybe think twice before they leave the house dressed up as an outdated racist stereotype.

so i'm trying to think of productive ways we can confront these issues, have these conversations with strangers, without emotionally exhausting ourselves or decreeing ourselves the Official Judge and Jury of all things Cultural Appropriating. here's my first idea.





this week, i got a lovely gift in the mail from kate burch: a zine called Head Dress. earlier this summer, kate asked me if she could quote me in it and i was very curious to see how it would turn out. now that i have a copy to myself, i'm really happy to have been a small part of what is a very informative yet simple to-the-point zine. when i asked her where i could suggest my readers buy it, she simply said that she wanted it to be more of a "public service announcement" than making money. so! print out a bunch of your own copies and drop them off where you think they might be most thought-provoking. a few ideas:
  • thrift stores where you regularly see "hipsters"
  • coffee shops in urban areas
  • music venues/festivals where you have seen aforementioned cultural appropriating hipsters
  • offending stores that sell clothes labelled "tribal" or "native" or "cherokee" (urban outfitters, forever21, bluefly, etc)

an urban outfitters totem pole jewelry stand. i shit you not.
  • hell, you could even mail copies to offending designers if you wanted! at fashion design schools.
suggest more places in the comments!

as for distribution, i've got québec city covered (going to translate it this weekend), and kate dropped a bunch around nyc, so readers everywhere else! arm your photocopiers! spread the word. it's nice to think these conversations can leave the blogosphere and can perhaps influence critical thinking. where do you guys live? can someone promise to cover kensington market in toronto? mile end in montreal? bushwick in brooklyn? portland?

so that's what's on my mind lately... i'll leave you with an few excerpts from the most recent post at my culture is not a trend in response to hate mail they've been receiving.

Stop being angry about the distant past. The people who colonized you are dead. Get over it.

Okay, I’ll play your game.

Lets pretend, and put aside the past, the genocide, the theft of land, peoples and language - all things deemed to have happened “long ago.” I’m not going to address these at all.

So here we are- modern day, new slate.

The act of cultural drag is still a problem. This is because systematic racism of Native American people still exists, and is overwhelmingly aggressive. We are still encountering it every day of our lives - in textbooks, at school, going shopping, using government facilities, interacting with the police, with health care systems, with our religious freedom, with the colour of our skin - we are met with derision and antagonism for our mere existence. With words used to keep us in our place. This is not ancient history, it is the every-day existence of a people who are still alive.

...When you choose to dress up like one of us, you erase us. You transform a group of doctors, writers, trades people, teenagers, mothers, fathers, singers — individuals, into one absurd caricature unworthy of respect, identity - autonomy.

...If our countries start to think of us as human beings, then our deeper issues may one day come to resolution as well. Just because my mission seems trivial - what impact could fashion possibly have?- doesn’t mean I’m not actively fighting the system that imposed the ideologies in the first place.

LINKS:

Kate Burch's tumblr

Download at zine library here.

Accosted by racist costumes: Expressing displeasure with something no one else has a problem with means revealing yourself as "the other" by Katrina Richardson

"Eskimo Sisters" in Indian headdresses by Newspaper Rock: Where Native America meets pop culture

Eskimo on Wikipedia

Ohnotheydidn't's feminist livejournal community is currently having a discussion aboutcultural appropriation.

my culture is not a trend

OFFENSIVE HALLOWEEN SHIT I RECOMMEND NOT LOOKING AT:

Adult Indian Squaw Wig with Braids

11 comments:

Dorothy Cheng said...

Great post. I've been following your blog (and also threadbared) for awhile and am really enjoying it. I've become completely fed up with the willful ignorance everywhere and constantly trying to confront people without making them feel defensive... which fails most of the time. I wish I had the luxury of being able to not notice or ignore this stuff. I'm not Native American, but as an Asian woman, I've had my share of fucked up experiences.

Jenny said...

I've seen this in Montreal on hipster girls at parties.I told one that her outfit was racist and to think a little harder about her "fashion" choice, and her uncritical consumption. I live in Montreals mile end...will print some of the zines out and leave them at the vintage shops and phonopolis record store in the neighborhood!

The Rejectionist said...

This is so great. Thank you. Also a longtime follower/lurker/enjoyer of all your fabulous insights and many splendid outfits.

Jenny said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Eireann said...

thank you for this--so much I've been trying to articulate, you've said clearly (and given me resources to learn from).

minnaar said...

Thank you for, again, writing about cultural appropriation. Sadly enough it is a completely new issue for me (there is no discussion about it in the Netherlands AT ALL - even though we have a very rich colonial past and many foods, fashions and other delights from it - and our racist celebration of Sinterklaas) but your posts and occasional tumblr entries get me more informed and able to take a critical look at Dutch cultural appropriation. Thank you so much,

Andrew said...

Not an entirely new issue for me. Then again I suppose being disabled (and going to a specialty school) tends to have these issues brought up and paid attention to more often than not.

At an intellectual level I want to applaud your work and show appreciation for people that won't take the current status quo as right.

On a gut level, partially due to RL problems, I'm just a bit too apathetic at the moment to feel emotional on the matter. Then again my gut also wants to lash out at the constant barrage of bitchy against the 'opressive white men' which I happen to be. What about how men are portrayed in media as stupid, unimaginative, completely lost without a woman to lead them around by the nose. THERE is a stereotype that needs to be stamped out here and now before it can gain a further foothold as acceptable (even though it already is, sadly.) God help you if you're a white man that, wait for it, actually wishes to speak of feelings and emotion

I will keep reading, you seem well spoken and I applaud your use of descriptive text for the more... busy images. Don't personally need said text, but it's still appreciated.

venusinfauxfurs said...

i think that is such a great idea as a flyer. since i live in hawaii i rarely see the appropriation of native americans instead see it all the time with the native hawaiian culture. as a part hawaiian it always makes me cringe to see hipsters in the national and international media appropriate ukuleles (although it was an "interpretation" of a portugese instrument. i only know this since i had a great grandfather who was portugese).

i'm tired of hawaiian culture being either portrayed as grass skirts, coconut bras and flower leis or the hula and its music being dumbed down and westernized to be mainstream. what sickens me the most is how so many hawaiians sell themselves to perpetuate these stereotypes within the tourist industry. the only thing i can really compare it to is the hollywood movies of the 1930s when they had african american actors playing the "jolly fool". unfortunately, my great grandmother who was a respected and award winning musician who only did traditional hawaiian music had a half sister who is the most famous example of the "jolly fool" that has ever been in the american media, hilo hattie.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilo_Hattie

recently, pbs hawaii did a show about hawaiian heritage and she was there biggest example of a sell out and mockery to hawaiians. after her death her husband (who is white) sold her name to be used as a store name for "hawaiian" products geared to tourists. it makes me feel somewhat better to know that my great grandmother, hilo hattie's half sister, treated the hawaiian culture with dignity and managed to be sucessful and respected. i apologize for practically writing an essay.

Pamela Myers said...

I feel surprised that I have never heard of cultural appropriation, although still aware of it as an occurrence. Perhaps I am too detached to fully understand. (I am Irish, which has the comparatively unique position of suffering the same occurrences of invasion, taking of land, destroying of heritage and language yet still remaining a majority and eventually recovering Independence.)

I am glad that you have made me more aware of this issue which has allowed to be more aware of the consequences and implications of seemingly frivolous actions.

I know it is beside the point and doesn't address the issue. But in regards to the festival girls with blue face paint, this might sooth your annoyance. It is common here for people to wear blue paint at festivals, I think it is a reference to the celts who, for many reasons, wore it for war. I am not sure if celts wore feathers too, but I can't imagine why they wouldn't have used them. Perhaps these girls were imitating that blue paint music festival trend.

Though they probably weren't!

waverlyandwaverly.com said...

I read this post several weeks ago when you first wrote it, and though I never commented on it (sometimes I am internet shy!), it definitely stuck with me. A friend of mine recently wrote an article about the inappropriateness of Native American (Halloween) costumes, and I thought you might be interested in reading it.

http://www.dailytexanonline.com/content/firing-line-inappropriate-costume

As soon as I read it, I thought back on your intelligent, thought-provoking post here.

Charles Allen said...

this was a very thought provoking and informative article. i didn't see what you thought about the responses in the cultural appropriation "bingo"? why is it on this article?

Post a Comment